A Gentle Feast Reviews: What Homeschool Families Actually Say

By A Gentle Feast·Language Arts · History · Literature · Geography · Science/Nature Study · Bible · Citizenship · Art · Music · Foreign Language · Latin

6 video reviews: 5 positive

A Gentle Feast draws consistent praise from reviewers for one thing above all: it puts a whole family on the same four-year history cycle. Several reviewers chose it specifically so children of different ages could study the same time period together, with readings split into forms (grades 1-3, 4-6, 7-9, 10-12) and family-style morning time pulling everyone to the table. The longest-term user in this set bought it when her oldest was six and is still using it at eleven, calling it a launching point rather than a scripted curriculum — open and go, with the full grade 1-12 book list and training videos available from purchase, and a one-time payment that buys lifetime access to a cycle. Reviewers also like that book selections sit at an age-appropriate reading level, so kids can take over their own readings earlier than with Ambleside Online, and one roundup ranked it first among Charlotte Mason packages for the parent training and phone support behind it.

The pushback comes from a reviewer who left after one year: she found the books okay but less rich than Ambleside Online's list, felt the history readings ran thin in stretches (a single historical novel carried American history for several weeks), and was frustrated she couldn't see the next cycle's full book list before buying. She also pegged it as the most expensive of the Charlotte Mason options she compared, with morning time plans sold as a separate add-on. Math is not scheduled — only suggestions — and there is no kindergarten level, since the program follows Charlotte Mason's view that formal lessons start at six.

Synthesized from 6 independent video reviews — every claim sourced from what real homeschool parents said on camera.

A good fit if…

Christian families with several children who want everyone studying the same history period together, Charlotte Mason-style, in an open-and-go format that still leaves the parent in charge of the method.

Probably skip if…

Parents who want the richest classic book list, a scheduled math curriculum, a kindergarten level, or fully scripted day-by-day lesson plans should look elsewhere.

The reviews (6)

A Gentle Feast Charlotte Mason Homeschool Curriculum Review! ❤️ 📚 Discover "A Gentle Feast," the perfect Charlotte Mason-inspired, family-centered homeschool curriculum in our review video. This paper-based curriculum brings your family together while adhering to Charlotte Mason's principles. Dive into living ideas, a complete curriculum, and a supportive online parent portal with lesson plans for grades 1-12. 📖 Customize with optional elements like a Morning Time Bundle, Teacher Planner, and Language Arts Student Packets. Join me in exploring this transformative four-year history cycle. If you're ready for a homeschooling game-changer, watch now! 🌟 Support the channel and buy through my affiliate link❤️: https://www.thefeastlife.me/a/2147894037/Lxz25bwk AND USE CODE for a discount: REBECCA Thank you (& PLEASE SUBSCRIBE😁)! My Online Course 👌 (Homeschool Parenting Program❤️) HERE: https://howdoihomeschool.com/homeschool-parenting-program/ My Curriculum (BJU Press) 😍: https://www.bjupresshomeschooling.com/site/include.php?id=63 My Homeschool Community (Made2Homeschool): https://www.made2homeschool.com/a/2147529243/ZtRNyKGY Veritas Press FREE Consultation🙌: https://love.veritaspress.com/rebecca-howdoihomeschool/ Contact me by email: rebeccadevitt@howdoihomeschool.com My Websites (FREEBIES ON HOMEPAGE😁): howdoihomeschool.com Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/howdoihomeschool Twitter: https://twitter.com/RebeccaDevitt5 Pinterest: https://www.pinterest.com.au/rebbeccadevitt/ #AGentleFeast #CharlotteMasonHomeschool #HomeschoolCurriculum #FamilyCenteredEducation #CharlotteMasonInspired #LivingBooks #Homeschooling #HomeschoolingReview #EducationUnboxed #AGentleFeastReview

PositiveHow to Homeschool

Top 5 Charlotte Mason Curriculums EXPLAINED! Are you curious about some of the top names in Charlotte Mason circles? Do you want to discover which curriculum will be a good fit for your family? This video is for you! I've been around the block in CM circles a few times now and in this video I discuss some of the ins and outs of each of the five biggest names in CM curriculums. To learn more about, or purchase A Gentle Feast, the curriculum we do use: https://agentlefeast.com/?ref=jonsay2010 __________________________________ Let's be friends! IG - https://www.instagram.com/kindle_togetherness/ Sign up for our email list & a freebie: https://kindletogetherness.myflodesk.com/426199f1-5e8e-436b-8696-7eb6075d4eb7 OUR WEBSITE: https://www.kindletogetherness.com COLLABS: kindletogetherness@gmail.com 📦 AMAZON SHOP - https://www.amazon.com/shop/kindletogetherness __________________________________ #amblesideonline #ambleside #simplycharlottemason #agentlefeast #thealveary #alveary #thecmec #cmec #curriculumreview #homeschoolcurriculum #charlottemason #charlottemasonhomeschool #homeschooling THANKS FOR WATCHING!!! ___________________________________ AFFILIATE NOTICE I do get a small commission if you use the links above. It is always a NO cost to you! Thank you for supporting our channel and helping me make time away from my family count. :)

PositiveKindle Togetherness

A GENTLE FEAST vs MORNING VIRTUES | Charlotte Mason Enrichment Curriculum Comparison Free Enrichment Guide: https://thishomeschoolhouse.com/resource-library-optin/ Get a good comparison between A Gentle Feast Morning Time and Morning Virtues from Gentle and Classical Press. Both of these are fantastic Enrichment Curriculum options, but they do differ quite a lot in how they are laid out. A Gentle Feast: https://agentlefeast.com/product/cycle-1-morning-time-bundle-option-1-2023-version-digital/ Morning Virtues: https://shopgentleclassical.com/collections/morning-virtues?srsltid=AfmBOor05aqGhKtyhOoINyicWCAuVSmStkCPSYlR-0Tws1h6tzSBTEVG Made2Homeschool Community: https://www.made2homeschool.com/a/2147529243/2MmyoMjA My Shop: shop.thishomeschoolhouse.com BLOG: https://www.thishomeschoolhouse.com IG: https://www.instagram.com/this.homeschool.house Email for Collabs / Business: contact@thishomeschoolhouse.com 📦MY AMAZON SHOP - https://www.amazon.com/shop/influencer-8b2f30ac Chapters: __________________________________ VIDEOS YOU MIGHT LIKE: 🎥 How to Start Homeschooling - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3pN8HdC2VSQ&t=1s 🎥 Homeschool Essentials - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aE0Kyc1nTTY&t=58s 🎥 Free Preschool Curriculum - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qpjOWDEEKYA&t=8s 🎥 Homeschool Room Tour - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6acae-ROO2U

PositiveThis Homeschool House

The Best Charlotte Mason Language Arts Curriculum | CHARLOTTE MASON INSPIRED HOMESCHOOL I've been a huge fan of Charlotte Mason ever since I read the book "For the Children's Sake" by Susan Schaeffer Macaulay (https://amzn.to/2QdDveS) when I first started homeschooling. (See all my favorite homeschool mom books here: https://amzn.to/2P5kmLi ). One of my goals was to find the best language arts curriculum that guided me in a Charlotte Mason style. I want to help you pick a good CM language arts curriculum. There are LOTS of options out there, I will list some, but it is definitely not all. Let’s look at what CM language arts would entail, so you can pick a good one that may fit this basic criteria. NEW to Homeschooling? READY SET HOMESCHOOL ➡️ My Step By Step Guide to get started homeschooling https://www.joyfulnoiselearning.com/ready-set-homeschool QUIZ: WHAT IS YOUR HOMESCHOOLING STYLE✏️ https://www.tryinteract.com/share/quiz/5eb07641bed8430014a171cd * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * MENTIONS IN THIS VIDEO Five in a Row - https://www.amazon.com/shop/joyfulnoiselearninghelpforhomeschoolers?listId=1W1U4BHP541AS&ref=idea_share_inf A Gentle Feast - https://agentlefeast.com/?ref_old=ashleyweaver356%40gmail.com My Father’s World - https://www.amazon.com/shop/joyfulnoiselearninghelpforhomeschoolers?listId=1W1U4BHP541AS&ref=idea_share_inf Beautiful Feet Books - http://bfbooks.com/?tap_a=30494-e48ebf&tap_s=957182-60cc65 Simply Charlotte Mason - https://simplycharlottemason.com/store/product-category/product-language-arts/ Ambleside Online - https://www.amblesideonline.org/curriculum.shtml Peaceful Press - https://www.thepeacefulpreschool.com/ First Language Lessons - https://www.amazon.com/shop/joyfulnoiselearninghelpforhomeschoolers?listId=1W1U4BHP541AS&ref=idea_share_inf Gentle Grammar - https://momdelights.com/index.php/downloads/ Sonlight - https://www.sonlight.com/ SEE MANY OF MY FAVORITE LANGUAGE ARTS CURRICULUMS HERE: https://amzn.to/3lr1mmY * * * * * * * * * * * * * Welcome to Joyful Noise Learning! I’m Ashley and I have homeschooled my 3 kids since 2013. I’m a curriculum research junky and buyer, and I love making my Biblically based, affordable, Charlotte Mason inspired homeschooling fun for my kids and love to have you join along in this journey. MORE ON JOYFUL NOISE LEARNING YOUTUBE🌸 The Good and the Beautiful vs. All About Reading - https://youtu.be/Az-Ar98Am0M Charlotte Mason Habit and Character Training for Kids - https://youtu.be/MSjftlQ7D6c How to do Science for FREE: https://youtu.be/vp1OhpqnOWs Day in the Life with My Kindergartner - https://youtu.be/cNWio28qdxw * * * * * * * * * * * * * FREEBIES FOR YOU For FREE Download for the Best PRESCHOOL RESOURCES 🌸 https://joyful-noise-learning.ck.page/5e3b898071 For FREE Download for the Best KINDERGARTEN RESOURCES 🌸 https://joyful-noise-learning.ck.page/9614c6b042 Need help with Planning? Check out my planning printables here: https://www.joyfulnoiselearning.com/ #languageartscurriculum #charlottemason DISCLAIMER: This video and description contains Amazon affiliate links, which means that if you click on one of the product links, I’ll receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. I am not associated with Amazon, but promote links to Amazon.

PositiveJoyful Noise Learning with Ashley W.

Comparing the Charlotte Mason Curriculums We’ve Used in Our Homeschool #charlottemason #homeschoolhistory #homeschool #homeschoolcurriculum #homeschoollife #homeschoolmom #simplehomeschool #homeschoolingmom #homeschoolmomlife #christianhomeschool #simpleliving #christianhomemaker We’ve used a few different Charlotte Mason curriculums in our honeschool. In this video I compare them and discuss how they work, and why we ultimately changed from one to another. Interested in trying Simply Charlotte Mason? Use my coupon code HUMBLY10 to get 10% off your orders! Simply Charlotte Mason - https://simplycharlottemason.com/ref/r7hu9/ *Affiliate* ⭐️FREE RESOURCES Here's one of the many free resources I offer over on my blog. Sign up for my newsletter when you visit to get first access to new printables & resources. Weekly Homeschool Checklist - https://humblyrootedhome.com/free-weekly-homeschool-checklist-printable-edit-in-canva/ Weekly Calendar Printable - https://humblyrootedhome.com/free-printable-weekly-schedule-for-all-your-planning-needs/ Timetable Printable - https://humblyrootedhome.com/free-weekly-calendar-printable-with-time-slots/ Amazon Storefront with all of my homeschooling & homemaking favorites: As an Amazon Associate, I earn a commission when your purchase through my affiliate links. https://www.amazon.com/shop/humblyrootedhome?ref_=cm_sw_r_cp_ud_aipsfshop_K4YYSZBRB63ZAN81GSMK About My Channel I'm Haley — a Christian homemaker & homeschooling mom of three boys. I love to share practical tips and ideas for helping you keep your home and homeschool running smoothly. I share curriculum reviews, systems, meal planning ideas, and more! _Other Places to Follow Me:_ Pinterest: https://pin.it/4UhznTso6f Blog: www.humblyrootedhome.com *Shop More of my Favorites Links!* -Not Consumed Homeschool Bible Studies: https://bit.ly/3sIb24p -Organic Survival Garden Seeds: https://bit.ly/3G6Aa8b -Toups and Co Non-Toxic Makeup and Skincare: https://bit.ly/46eDNmY -Hopefuel Faith Planner - https://bit.ly/40KtTIF Collabs and Business Inquiries: humblyrooted1@gmail.com

PositiveHumbly Rooted Home

7 BEST Charlotte Mason Homeschool Curriculum Packages? ❤️👌 Charlotte Mason had a unique approach to education which is perfect for homeschools. Many curriculum companies have modeled their curriculum, so it follows her approach. This video shows some of the best charlotte mason homeschool curriculum programs available today. Hope you enjoy them. 😊 These are the ones I talked about 🙌(affiliate links included): Ambleside Online: https://amblesideonline.org/ Living Books Curriculum: https://charlottemasonhomeschooling.com/ Simply Charlotte Mason: https://simplycharlottemason.com/ref/g6zjy/ Charlotte Mason in a Box: https://www.queenhomeschool.com/categories/charlotte-mason-in-a-box-kits/ Heart of Dakota: https://heartofdakota.idevaffiliate.com/104.html A Gentle Feast: https://www.thefeastlife.me/a/2147894037/Lxz25bwk AND USE CODE for a discount: REBECCA Masterbooks: https://www.christianbook.com/page/homeschool/master-books?event=AFF&navcat=Homeschool|Curriculum-Index|Master-Books&p=1225968 SECULAR Charlotte Mason Option - Nautilus Homeschool: https://www.nautilushomeschool.com/?via=rebecca My Online Course 👌 (Homeschool Parenting Program❤️) HERE: https://howdoihomeschool.com/homeschool-parenting-program/ My Community (Made2Homeschool): https://www.made2homeschool.com/a/2147529243/ZtRNyKGY My Curriculum (BJU Press) 😍: https://www.bjupresshomeschooling.com/site/include.php?id=63 Veritas Press FREE Consultation🙌: https://love.veritaspress.com/rebecca-howdoihomeschool/ Contact me by email: rebeccadevitt@howdoihomeschool.com My Websites (FREEBIES ON HOMEPAGE😁): howdoihomeschool.com Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/howdoihomeschool Twitter: https://twitter.com/RebeccaDevitt5 Pinterest: https://www.pinterest.com.au/rebbeccadevitt/ Affiliate links used in this description box! #charlottemasonhomeschool #charlottemasoncurriculum #charlottemason #besthomeschoolcurriculum

UnclearHow to Homeschool

In their words

I purchased the curriculum myself to use when my son was six my eldest and we have actually stuck with it he is now 11 and we are still happy and content and using it and thriving

that is really what I love about a gentle Feast is it's a launching point but it is not a scripted curriculum

basically all your kids can study the same thing only at different levels of difficulty

what I will say about the book selections with the gentle feast is that I feel like they are assigned at a very age appropriate reading level

the books with the gentle fees were okay. They served their purpose, but they weren't as rich as the books that Amblesside Online offers in their book list

I like this program because it gives you a curriculum you can follow and it gives you everything you will need but it also gives you so much training as a parent

What reviewers praise

  • One history cycle combines all ages family-style · 4 reviewers
  • Parent training videos, calls, and support included · 3 reviewers
  • Covers grades 1 through 12 in four forms · 3 reviewers
  • Open and go; a full year in one purchase · 2 reviewers
  • Flexible launching point, not rigidly scripted · 2 reviewers
  • Age-appropriate book levels enable independent reading

Common complaints

  • Book list less rich than Ambleside Online's
  • History readings run thin in stretches
  • Most expensive of compared Charlotte Mason options
  • Morning time plans cost extra
  • No scheduled math curriculum included
  • Next cycle's book list not visible before purchase

Would A Gentle Feast fit your homeschool?

Reviews tell you what worked for someone else's kid. A 5-minute profile tells you what's likely to work for yours — matched across 1,307 programs, free, no signup needed to see your top picks.

Common questions

What grades does A Gentle Feast cover?+

It covers grades 1 through 12, divided into four forms: form one is grades 1-3, form two is 4-6, form three is 7-9, and form four is 10-12. There is no kindergarten level — the program follows Charlotte Mason's principle that formal school shouldn't start until age six, though younger children can join morning time informally.

Can I teach multiple kids together with A Gentle Feast?+

Yes — this is the program's signature strength. When you buy a cycle you're buying a time period, and all your children ages six through eighteen study that same period at their own form's level. Morning time brings everyone together, history readings can be shared or combined across forms, and nature study works as a family activity.

How does the A Gentle Feast history rotation work?+

It runs on a four-year history cycle. Form one students focus on American history; a world history stream is added around fourth grade and an ancient history stream around fifth. After completing all four cycles, families loop back to cycle one at a higher level with different assigned books.

Is A Gentle Feast scripted and open-and-go?+

Reviewers describe it as open and go but deliberately not scripted — one long-term user calls it a launching point that teaches you the Charlotte Mason method through included training videos rather than handing you word-for-word lesson scripts. A full year comes in one purchase, with the whole grade 1-12 book list accessible from day one.

How much does A Gentle Feast cost compared to other Charlotte Mason curricula?+

It's a paid curriculum — one reviewer who compared it to Ambleside Online (free plans) and Living Heritage called it the most expensive of the three. However, it's a one-time purchase with lifetime access to a cycle rather than an annual membership, and books are purchased separately with free online options linked where available. Morning time plans are a separate add-on.

Does A Gentle Feast include math?+

No. It covers all other content areas — history, literature, science, language arts, and morning time enrichment — but math is not scheduled. The author provides math suggestions, so you'll need to choose a separate math curriculum.